|
|
|
The traditional perceptions of the Transnistrian conflict and the methods of resolving it, formed in the period before the launch of the Russian aggression against Ukraine, are no longer relevant. Chisinau should get ready for the institution of a new international format for political settlement in Transnistria, actively contributing at diplomatic level to its establishment...
|
Anatol Țăranu |
|
“This summit wasn’t about NATO, but I raised this issue,” Volodymyr Zelensky stated in a crowded conference hall at the Mimi Castle complex of the Republic of Moldova, where the summit that involved 50 European leaders had just ended. Indeed, this meeting shouldn’t have been at all about the Alliance, but particular statements made there actually brought Ukraine half a step closer to NATO. The same thing can be said about the security problem of the Republic of Moldova, which wasn’t announced expressly in the summit’s agenda, but relevant statements were made on this dimension, with evident practical consequences.
Moldova’s security is guaranteed by Ukrainian Army
First of all, both President Sandu and other European officials admitted that the security of the Republic of Moldova is primarily guaranteed by Ukraine. Without the heroic resistance of the Ukrainian Army before the Russian aggressor, the Republic of Moldova could have stopped existing as a state. In particular, this special role of Ukraine in guaranteeing the security of the Moldovan state was the reason why Volodymyr Zelensky was so warmly welcomed in Bulboaka. President Sandu met the Ukrainian leader the first and went out to meet other invitees of the summit only after she finished the separate negotiations with Volodymyr Zelensky.
These negotiations between two leaders were short, of only 15-20 minutes, but had a powerful informational impact supplemented with special political symbolism. It should be noted that Volodymyr Zelensky made long awaited statements as a result of the summit, which officially closed the page of particular ambiguities between Ukraine and Moldova concerning the pressing problem of Transnistria. They ultimately stated that Transnistria is a land under Russian occupation and this was consequently for the first time that the key states of the West started to publicly admit this. The value of such acknowledgement of the character of the Transnistrian conflict is amplified by the fact that the summit itself was symbolically held on the border of the occupation zone, which is Transnistria.
Russian fake news denied on warm trails
Towards the end of the summit day, the tête-à-tête meeting of the Moldovan and Ukrainian leaders produced a real explosion in the Russian information space where it was literally announced that Maia Sandu agreed to allow the Armed Forces of Ukraine to enter Moldova for “cleaning” Transnistria. This fake news appeared on the Telegram channels for disseminating the Russian narrative about the war in Ukraine and was then massively circulated by the Russian propaganda media and Russian politicians and, regrettably, was believed by the Ukrainian Telegram channels and even by some of the media outlets that didn’t bother about verifying the facts.
In reality, this news was fully invented information. President Sandu didn’t make at all statements on this issue! The advertising turned out to be of such a nature that the presidential administration in Chisinau had to swiftly issue a statement to deny this fake news, while Zelensky had to answer in a surprised way journalists’ relevant questions, assuring that Ukraine will not conduct a military operation in Transnistria if Chisinau does not ask for this.
Aggressor in the role of peacekeeper?
This statement by the Ukrainian President brought to an end the discussions about the possibility of unilateral actions by Kyiv against the group of Russian troops from the left side of the Nistru even if earlier there were indeed thoughts about the possibility of military actions by Kyiv in Transnistria for annihilating the military danger for Ukraine in this region. It is enough to make reference to the suggestive name of a detailed article from Euro Pravda: “Time has come to liquidate Transnistria. How should Ukraine act in this regard and how it cannot act”. But at the summit it became clear that the Ukrainian army will not intervene in Transnistria without the consent of Chisinau and Zelensky’s relevant promise became public.
Another border statement of the Ukrainian President at the summit refers to the international format of the so-called Transnistrian settlement. Zelensky announced the death of the current 5+2 format and this statement can be interpreted only as a call to cardinally reform the international mechanism for mediating the political settlement of the conflict in Moldovan Transnistria, by diminishing the decisive role of Russia in this process. The main thing is that the opinions of Kyiv and Chisinau about the Transnistrian issue coincide in both of the positions formulated by Volodymyr Zelensky at the summit in Bulboaca.
A pan-European security summit
Nevertheless, the main security problem for Moldova was related not to the fake news about Transnistria, but to the real and urgent needs of Ukraine in the war with Russia. The impenetrability of the Ukrainian shield is the most powerful guarantee of Moldova’s security. Volodymyr Zelensky for the first time came with the idea that the Western allies should start to create a “patriotic coalition”, which is a unity of states that will work to supply Ukraine with armament and to offer it political support for entry into NATO. It is noteworthy that this idea of Ukraine found support at the summit immediately after it was formulated. In particular, the Prime Minister of the Netherlands stated that Ukraine needs more “Patriot” systems, while Romania signed a document by which it undertook to support Ukraine in the process of joining the Alliance. However, the “coalition” asked by Zelensky is still at the formation stage and Kyiv has yet to work to implement this idea that was publicly expressed for the first time at the summit in Moldova.
In short, the European Political Community Summit held in Bulboaca normally turned into a pan-European security summit. As it always happens in security issues, the meeting left several open questions. For example, after Zelensky officially presented the position on the possibility of the Ukrainian Armed Forces’ participation in the freeing of Transnistria from Russians and ultimately officially “killed” the 5+2 format of the Transnistrian conflict settlement talks, there are questions as to the new formula for settling the separatist conflict on the left side of the Nistru. For now, there is no detailed agreement on the new international Transnistrian conflict settlement format.
Nevertheless, it is more than evident that the future mechanism for resolving the dispute in Transnistria will no longer be dominated by Moscow. The war that is being waged by Putin’s Russia against Ukraine turned separatist Transnistria into a real enclave that is clearly isolated from the until recently decisive military and economic protection of Russia. The fact that President Zelensky excluded Ukraine’s military involvement in Transnistria in the absence of Chisinau’s consent does not mean at all that this variant cannot be applied in principle. The most relevant thing in this situation is Moscow’s more than limited capacity to militarily protect the separatist Tiraspol.
Transnistrian conflict under new geopolitical realities
The new geopolitical realities in which the Transnistrian conflict in the Republic of Moldova is now, with these realities being shaped at the European summit in Bulboaca, are yet to be fully realized and acknowledged by Chisinau. The traditional perceptions of the Transnistrian conflict and the methods of resolving it, formed in the period before the launch of the Russian aggression against Ukraine, are no longer relevant. Chisinau should get ready for the institution of a new international format for the political settlement in Transnistria, actively contributing at diplomatic level to its establishment.
The fact that the separatist leader in Tiraspol, Krasnoselsky, immediately after the summit stated that the 5+2 format of the talks should be restored reveals Moscow’s interest in this settlement format that actually served the cause of conflict freezing. Chisinau is obliged to learn the lesson of the delay in the Transnistrian settlement imposed by Moscow and to avoid this scenario in the future. The first conclusion of the learned lesson dictates the condition of admission of the separatist Transnistrian regime as a party to the talks within the new international settlement format only if the territorial integrity of the Republic of Moldova, in whose composition Transnistria will have a special status in accordance with the Constitution and the laws adopted by Chisinau, is recognized. The debates held on the sidelines of the European summit in Bulboaca shaped the platform for political support for such a conflict settlement scenario and for strengthening the Republic of Moldova’s security this way.
doctor of history, political commentator
IPN publishes in the Op-Ed rubric opinion pieces submitted by authors not affiliated with our editorial board. The opinions expressed in these articles do not necessarily coincide with the opinions of our editorial board.
CPE
See related articles:
- Nicu Popescu: Organization of EPC Summit strengthened Moldova’s place among European states
-
- Why and how the third EPC Summit Matters for Moldova. Op-Ed by Dr. Dorina Baltag
- Ruslan Codreanu: It is normal to unite around European integration
- The EPC's Impact on Moldova and Ukraine's European Future. Op-ed by Dr. Dorina Baltag
- Mihai Bologan: I think Moldovans understand CPE Summit had a big positive impact
- Vlad Kulminski: EPC Summer irritated Russia to the maximum
- Victor Juc: Diplomatic service should strengthen dialogue initiated on platform of EPC Summit
- EPC Summit - diplomatic success for Moldova. IPN debate
- European Political Community – Europe without aggressive Russia. Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Cristina Lesnic: It would be immoral and cynical not to try and integrate into EU with pragmatic solution for Transnistrian region
- Alexandru Flenchea: Moldova should be an active part of security arrangements in Europe
- EPC Summit – signals for Moldova’s reintegration and integration into EU. IPN debate
- Nicolae Ciubuc: Limited access to European funds is one of problems that prevent us from becoming competitive
- Gheorghe Gaberi: Farmers should be prepared to use last-generation technology for higher quality and yield
- Iurie Fală about EPC Summit and opportunities for agriculture: All Moldovan producers have a place on EU market
- Iurie Scripnic: Credit of trust obtained at EPC Summit should be used with maximum seriousness
- EPC Summit – opportunities opened up for high-value agriculture and export of Moldovan products. IPN debate
- "Those who look alike, take each other”– speech delivered in Chisinau by Ambassador of Italy to Moldova Lorenzo Tomassoni on occasion of Italy’s Republic Day
- Igor Munteanu: Transnistria is Moscow’s instrument of pressure against Moldova’s wish to become part of EU
- Dinu Plîngău: EU wants Moldova to maintain stability
- Ion Sula about results of EPC Summit: EU shows openness, but a lot of work is to be done internally
- EPC Summit – opportunities opened for acceleration of negotiations with EU. IPN debate
- Nicu Popescu: Purchase of radar system is this year’s priority
- Maia Sandu: EPC Summit showed that Moldova’s accession to EU is closer
- Siegfried Mureșan: EPC Summit was a success
- Maia Sandu: We should be glad and proud of having played host to EPC Summit
-
-
- The European Political Summit in Moldova: not just a ‘talking club’. Op-ed by Dr. Dorina Baltag
- Emmanuel Macron at EPC Summit: Moldova’s accession to EU is not only realizable, but is also a fact that is to be accomplished
- Volodymyr Zelensky: A united society is needed in Moldova
- Moldova will not abandon Transnistrian region in European integration process
- Polish Premier: We propose accelerating Moldova’s accession to EU
- Maia Sandu after EPC Summit: Today we showed our power and unity
- Czech Premier: EPC members want rules-based international order
- Norway to allocate €50m to Moldova
- Roberta Metsola about Moldova’s perspective of joining the EU in 2030: It depends on political aspects
- Klaus Iohannis: EPC Summit was a success
- Minister of Interior: Security picture is normal
- Klaus Iohannis at EPC Summit: EU and other partners are here for Moldova
- Giorgia Meloni: Italy supports path chosen by Ukraine, Moldova and Georgia
- Volodymyr Zelensky: Only strong coalition can defeat Russian terror
- EPC Summit has begun. Maia Sandu: We all have a strong interest in improving connectivity among countries
- Charles Michel: EPC Summit is the platform to coordinate everything related to energy, security and infrastructure
- Roberta Metsola: Moldova belongs in the European Union
- Josep Borrell at EPC Summit: Restoration of peace should be key issue
- EPC Summit: Volodymyr Zelensky and Maia Sandu make first statements for reporters
- Nicu Popescu in Bulboaca: We want our accession to EU to be accelerated
- Delegations at EPC Summit in the attention of over 650 journalists
- Ukrainian President Zelensky arrives at EPC Summit
- NATO planes secure Moldova Summit airspace
- Official delegations awaited in Bulboaca
- Summit 2023. Maia Sandu: Our performance depends on us all
-
- Twenty delegations will arrive in Moldova for EPC Summit today
- Piotr Komarov: EPC Summit will open new opportunities in energy efficiency
- Sergiu Tofilat: Russian gas that is supplied to Transnistrian region is a risk that still persists
- European Political Community Summit: stakes for Moldova
- Victor Parlicov: Raising of energy security at EPC Summit already means a lot
- EPC Summit, opportunities opened up for security and energy interconnection. IPN debate
- 48 delegations confirmed presence at EPC Summit in Moldova
- EPC agenda: quo vadis? Op-Ed by Dr. Dorina Baltag
- EU anti-corruption sanctions: a useful tool for eastward enlargement. Analysis by Dionis Cenuşa
- Nicu Popescu: We prepare important announcements that will be made at June 1 Summit
- The Power of Dialogue: Moldova Welcomes European Allies for EPC Summit. Op-Ed by Petru Culeac
- Moldova needs an investment fund for social enterprises, statement
- EPC Summit of June 1 considered an opportunity for discussing social economy and entrepreneurship
- The summit in Chisinau reinforces the special status of the outpost of the EU in the Caucasus. Op-Ed by Igor Chalenko, Ukraine
- Olaf Scholz: Moldova is not alone
- “Imaginary” aspect of social inclusion of the Roma should be excluded, “Voice of the Roma”
- Maria Șleahtițchi: Moldova has what to integrate with into culture of European community
- Dmitri Moruz: We must be attentive and ready to take opportunities offered by EPC Summit
- Romanies want to be part of European family, but ask for more information
- Andrei Chistol: After EPC Summit, European citizens’ interest in Moldova will grow
- EPC Summit, opportunities opened up for cultural interconnection. IPN debate
- EPC Summit, an opportunity to support states to be more active at geopolitical level in region, experts
- Nicu Popescu: EPC Summit is most important foreign policy event since Independence
- Traditional dessert and ice wine for European leaders attending EPC Summit
- Moldova, you are not alone! Messages of European officials ahead of EPC Summit
- Inhabitants of Bulboaca need special permits to be able to move on June 1
- Preparations in Bulboaca in full swing: EPC Summit is the largest foreign policy event
- Mihai Mogîldea: EPC Summit can bring more investments to Moldova
- Daniel Vodă: 44 leaders confirmed their presence at EPC Summit
-
- Ion Iordachi: Messages at EPC Summit are essential for investment climate
- Viorel Chivriga: EPC Summit will open up many ways for economic development
- Sergiu Manea: Through EPC Summit, Moldova can show that it is a safe destination
- EPC Summit – responsibilities and economic opportunities opened for Moldova. IPN debate
- Victoria Roșa: Thanks to EPC Summit, Moldova will be at the center of Europe and on EU agenda
- Chiril Moțpan: Organization of EPC Summit in Moldova is a source of pride
- Octavian Țîcu: European leaders made a brave decision picking Moldova to host EPC Summit
- National Assembly of May 21, stakes of event and political risks in connection with EPC Summit. IPN debate
- European assembly promises to become manifestation of abandonment of “Russian world”. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- Cultural events for delegations attending EPC Summit
- What’s at stake for the EU at the European Political Community Summit? Op-Ed by Dr. Dorina Baltag
- Maps with alternative routes through Chisinau in connection with EPC Summit
- 42 heads of state and government from Europe confirmed presence at EPC Summit
- Foreigners refused entry to Moldova during EPC summit to get temporary accommodation
- EPC Summit will increase Moldova’s fame and will open new doors to businesses, expert
- CPE summit expected to have major impact on most important sectors in Moldova
- About 350 international journalists to attend June 1 CPE Summit
- Sergiu Iurcu: Civil society can and should be an important voice at EPC Summit
- Andrei Curăraru: Civil society plays an important role in disseminating information about advantages of EPC Summit
- Mihai Mogîldea: Benefits of housing EPC Summit are larger than made investments
- EPC Summit, responsibilities and opportunities for civil society. IPN debate
- Police present maps with alternative routes in context of simulation for EPC Summit
- Nicu Popescu: Our objective is to bring country into EU by the end of this decade
- Central public authorities will be given priority in case of simultaneous rallies
- Strategic engagement, agenda-setting, and networking. Or how Moldova can leverage the EPC Summit. Op-ed by Dr. Dorina Baltag
- General simulation for EPC Summit to be held May 14
- Government invites mayors to take part in May 21 Assembly
- Ana Revenco: Security challenges can be overcome by communication, coordination and cooperation
- Republic of Moldova at the core of European policy. Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Senior state officials on Europe Day: We celebrate peace and unity of European family
- Citizens urged to avoid Chisinau-Bulboaca road during May 31-June 2
- “Movement for People” announces it will block a number of arteries on June 1
- 200 journalists from 23 countries accredited for EPC Summit during first week
- Alina Dandara about advantages of holding EPC Summit in Moldova
- Igor Klipii: It is not right to have separate solutions for Transnistrian region and Gagauzia in European integration process
- Eremei Prisyazhnyuk: EPC is a good platform for transition from Eastern Partnership to EU enlargement project
- European Political Community Summit: responsibilities and opportunities for political class. IPN debate
- Citizens urged to avoid Chisinau-Bulboaca road during May 31-June 2
- Key Expectations and Deliverables of the Upcoming EPC Summit in Moldova. Commentary by Iulian Groza
- Alexandru Tănase: Moldova should show responsibility to properly hold EPC Summit
- Alexandru Tănase: Moldova has always been pampered child of Europe
- Hundreds of persons expected to take part in June 1 summit
- Police simulate movement of delegations for June 1 summit
- June 1 – Day of the “child” Moldova. The day that will change the fate of our countryю Op-Ed by Dumitru Țîra
- Black Hawk helicopter to fly over Chisinau for several days as part of Moldovan-Polish drill
- How to obtain media accreditation for European Political Community Summit
- Free commutation tickets for participants in EPC Summit
- The European Political Community in Russia’s closeness: strengthening the "circle of friends" in the EU's neighborhood. Analysis by Dionis Cenușa
- On June 1, Moldova will become center of Europe, Maia Sandu