When it was in opposition, the current government declared that it would solve the problems of justice in a very short period of time, and many Moldovans gave their votes precisely because they believed in the promises about the judicial reform, says Victor Juc, director of the Institute for Legal, Political and Sociological Research.
“The government initiated this process being in a bit of a romantic mindset, I would say, because it did not carry out an expert assessment, which would have shown that this process is much more complicated. One thing is when you are in opposition and make a ton of promises, and another when you take power and have to actually implement these promises. So naturally, there are these critical voices in our society saying that the government has not yet fulfilled those commitments”, Victor Juc commented on the progress of the justice reform during an IPN debate.
While disagreeing with his fellow panelists that the government is “now bulldozing” through the judicial reform, Victor Juc admitted there is problem with communication and cooperation. According to him, when public consultations are organized with civil society members, their proposals are rarely taken into consideration by the government, leading the number of those interested in such meetings to decrease with every event.
“In addition, the government does not take into account the opinions of some parties in the immediate vicinity on the political spectrum. There are several parties whose leaders offer competent expertise in this field, but they say the government doesn’t listen”, added the expert.
In this context, Victor Juc emphasized that the relations between the state powers do not only involve separation, but also cooperation, as per Article 6 of the Constitution. “But this is ignored in Moldova, perhaps partially due to the lack of a political culture, a legal culture, a culture of cooperation”, says the expert.
Victor Juc also suggested that the government uses unorthodox methods to clean up the judiciary. “You cannot build a democracy with undemocratic methods. What is being tried in the Republic of Moldova - let us first fix the situation, and this will lead to democracy - is not correct. (...) I wouldn’t say that the self-administration bodies of justice are weak, as some say, but probably the people in the justice system understood a truth: politicians try to keep them under control, and even if there is a corporate solidarity in system, many still choose to submit rather than fight. This is a big problem for the Republic of Moldova”.
Regarding the bad opinion that many citizens have about the justice system, Victor Juc admitted that there are people in the system who have contributed to such a perception. “But there are two other determining factors. First of all, there is the political-administrative factor, that is, those people who argue the need for reform, claiming that the system is corrupt and ineffective, and here are the solutions”. And the second factor, according to Victor Juc, is the media coverage, because only errors and bad things get to be news.
Concluding on a more optimistic note, Victor Juc mentioned that “steps are being taken” in the justice reform, and for it to be successful, the support and supervision of Moldova’s development partners is needed.
The debate, titled “Justice reform: actions, results and consequences”, was held as part of IPN’s project “Support for the justice reform through media coverage in multimedia format of relevant cases of alleged injustice”.
Injustiția 2
See related articles:
- Legal framework should be improved to ensure greater protection for journalists, API
- Attacks on Moldovan journalists remain frequent, API
- APOTA: Judges who commit abuses should be penalized
- Non-penalizing of abuses in justice is cause of failure of transport reform, Association
- Premier urged to take measures to prevent bankruptcy of local renewable energy companies
- State pushes local renewable energy companies towards bankruptcy, statements
- Vadim Vieru: Are judges reduced to silence? Why aren’t they asked to say how justice reform should be done?
- Cristina Ciubotaru: The judiciary is not the third, but one of three branches of power
- Lack of communication and political influence are mistakes typical of all governments. Why does justice sector reform stagnate? IPN debate
- Lawyer Bazatin says legislative shortcomings on forced eviction should be dealt with
- Purchase of real estate for a business by a woman resulted in interminable dispute
- Those who are responsible for delays in trying of cases should be fined, lawyer
- Lawyer about cases pending in court, delays and incompetence
- Sentence in case of Basarabeasca mayor expected to be pronounced on Nov. 15
- Case of Basarabeasca mayor not yet decided after over five years
- Maia Bănărescu: Children and women should not be revictimized in court and those who reform justice sector should pay attention to this
- They don’t seek justice because they are ashamed - Parents don’t want society to know that their child was sexually abused
- Path to justice is too thorny: Why do some of victims give up obtaining justice
- CVR: Program to support Roma population does not contain major recommendations
- Problem of inclusion cannot be solved without direct participation of the Roma, CVR
- Local councilor calls on NAC and PO to probe actions of Cimișeni mayor
- Councilor accuses mayor of Cimișeni village of illegalities
- Persons from prosecution service are behind unauthorized construction from Ciocârlia St, lawyer
- Dwellers from Ciocârliei St angry with unauthorized building of block
- Lawyer Andrei Briceac: Justice should be done not on TV by politicians but in court of law. IPN interview
- Andrei Briceac: Justice sector reform does not mean only replacement of people and liquidation of institutions
- Lawyer: “Năstase-Usatyi” cases could repeat in next elections or justice sector reform will produce results?
- Appeals Court confirmed illegalities committed in “Gemeni” case, lawyer
- Some of citizens continue to look for their shares in SA “Gemeni”, lawyer
- Ilie Rotaru asks to determine legality of criminal cases sent to court by anticorruption prosecutors
- Ilie Rotaru accuses anticorruption prosecutors of fabrication of criminal cases
- Ilie Chirtoacă: If Moldova does not fulfill EU conditions concerning justice sector, it cannot continue on path of European integration
- Ilie Chirtoacă: During five years of death of Andrei Braguța, not much progress has been made in this case
- Ilie Chirtoacă: There is a connection between bomb threats and postponement of trials
- Medical personnel employed from among the police force encroach on rights of prisoners, report
- ECHR convicted Moldova for violating right to freedom
- Functionaries responsible for ECHR convictions should pay, statement
- Shortage of doctors has an impact on detainees’ access to necessary assistance, IDOM
- Maria Frunze: 4,000 cases are on hold at Centru branch of Chisinau Court. IPN interview
- Maria Funze: For human rights violations committed in Transnistrian region, damages awarded by ECHG are paid by Russia
- Judge: We risk seeing an increase in number of complains to ECHR about violation of reasonable case examination timeframe
- Vadim Vieru: All convictions of Moldova by ECHR could have been avoided if state had acted to protect human rights, IPN interview
- Vadim Vieru: Any case of conviction of Moldova at ECHR could have been prevented
- Most often Moldova is convicted by ECHR for ill-treatment and illegal arrests, lawyer
- Trades of “Sofia” Flower Market make call to municipality
- Traders of Flower Market “Sofia” accuse authorities of abusively removing their kiosks
- Valeriu Pașa: Justice sector reform is a slow process that will last for several years
- Valeriu Pașa: Justice over last few years turned into system of racket and outcry auctioning
- Valeriu Pașa: As a result of justice sector reform, some of judges and prosecutors should end up in jail
- Livia Mitrofan: No one saw our sincere wish to have judicial system reformed
- Igor Boțan: Important things were done in justice, but a system reform is yet needed
- Iuluan Groza: Courageous, competent and upright people from justice system should be at forefront
- State of justice sector reform on granting of EU candidate status: Conception, practical actions, effects, general perception. IPN debate
- Negotiations on accession to EU can last as long as we have foreign army on our territory, opinion
- After 30 years, role of peacekeeping mission in Security Zone continues to be disputed, opinion