|
|
|
The geopolitical narratives used by the governments of Georgia, Moldova and Armenia denote the increased degree of influence of exogenous processes on the dynamics of internal politics. Accordingly, responsibility for failures in the act of governance is diminished or even nullified...
|
Dionis Cenuşa, Senior Contributor |
|
The states of Eastern Europe are going through a process of geopolitical readjustment determined by the Russian military aggression against Ukraine and the geographical advancement of the European integration project. The manifestation of Russian militaristic revisionism against Ukrainian territorial integrity in February 2022 added to the previous policy of supporting separatism, which Moscow used against Georgia, Moldova, Azerbaijan and Ukraine after the collapse of the USSR. In parallel, the "awakening" or geopolitical maturation of the EU fueled the conversation about moving the borders of the expansion of the European integration project to the East, inside the post-Soviet space, perceived by Russia as its exclusive sphere of influence (IPN, 2023). In this context, the governments of Georgia, Moldova and Armenia, which have not changed since the beginning of the geopolitical crisis in February 2022, prefer very specific geopolitical narratives to relate to both their own citizens and external actors. The main foreign policy narratives that are used by policy makers in Tbilisi, Chisinau and Yerevan concern war, foreign interference and, last but not least, the process of European integration.
Three different (geo)political realities
In the case of the Georgian government headed by Irakli Kobahidze, foreign policy is transactional and therefore multi-vector. From this point of view, according to the Georgian side, European integration would not be endangered due to increased trade with Russia. The same style of foreign policy is characteristic of other neighbouring states, such as Turkey, Azerbaijan, Armenia (for now). Within and in the EU neighbourhood - Hungary and Serbia respectively - they act in a similar way to Georgia, without suffering financial consequences in relation to Brussels. However, like Turkey and Serbia, Georgia does not adhere to European sanctions against Russia, except those targeting the financial sector and the re-export of dual-use goods. If the behavior of the Georgian authorities had been an isolated case in the region, then the government in Tbilisi would have had a more cautious policy towards pro-EU domestic non-state actors, on which the law on "foreign influence agencies" begins to apply from August 2024 (GeorgiaToday, August 2024).
The current Moldovan government, dominated by President Maia Sandu, has a unilateral and unwavering position towards the pro-EU agenda. Any relationship with Russia, if it clashes with the European sanctions regime, is out of the question and official relations are frozen. Even the "5+2" format on the solution of the Transnistria conflict is suspended with the increasing likelihood of even being cancelled to lay the groundwork for negotiations in which Russia is not a party. Rapprochement with the EU and distancing from Russia are the basis of the current foreign policy of the Chisinau government, reflected also in the country’s new defence strategy, which states that the “aggressive policy” of the Russian state, including hybrid warfare operations, represents the main threat to Moldovan national security (RadioFreeEurope, July 2024). Although the authorities in Chisinau flatly refuse to acknowledge it, Russia’s aggression against Ukraine fueled Ukraine’s pro-EU accession diplomacy, which Moldova subsequently used (together with Georgia).
Somewhere in the middle lies Armenia, which decreases security dialogue with Russia (not in the economic dimension), and instead begins the process of “Europeanization” of internal security policies. Since gaining independence in the 1990s, Yerevan has shared with the Russian side some internal security responsibilities, such as controlling people entering Armenia through the Armenian capital’s international airport (RadioFreeEurope, July 2024). Thus, at the end of July, when the EU announced the start of visa liberalisation dialogue with Armenia, the Russian border police ended their mandate, after 32 years of monitoring the flow of people from abroad (Tass, July 2024). Although these processes have not been mutually conditional, the full restoration of its sovereignty over Armenia’s border control function will also facilitate compliance with the criteria for a liberalised visa regime with the EU (Reuters, July 2024).
Three geopolitical narratives in Georgia, Moldova and Armenia
War, foreign interference and European integration dominate the communication of the governments of the three capitals. In the pre-election situation in Georgia and Moldova, these themes are used by decision-makers to mobilize their own electorate. The parties in power in these countries - "Georgian Dream" and the Party of Action and Solidarity (PAS), respectively - use these narratives in an attempt to renew their political influence in parliament and in the office of the president, respectively. The situation is very different in Armenia, where Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan's Civic Contract party has consolidated its hold on power following early elections in June 2021, despite protests over the defeat in the Karabakh war in 2020. Unlike the recent anti-government protests in Georgia, organised on the basis of pro-EU sentiments by civil society, youth and opposition forces (April-June 2024), the protests in Armenia against the demarcation of the border with Azerbaijan are categorised by the government as attempts at destabilization by pro-Russian forces.
The war narrative frequently used by Georgian government leaders consists of making general accusations about the intention of the opposition and the non-existent "Global War Party" to drag Georgia into a military altercation against Russia, opening a "second front". This topic is used as a basis for arguing against pursuing a tough policy against Russia in solidarity with Ukraine. The war also figures in the discourse of the governing forces in Chisinau. They appeal to this narrative to explain the origin of the socio-economic crisis to which the population has been exposed, especially the most vulnerable categories (pensioners, rural population, etc.). The opposition often criticizes the PAS-Sandu government for excessively resorting to the issue of the war in Ukraine as a leitmotif to justify its failures in the act of governing, such as the galloping inflation of 2023, the flight of investors, the high rate of emigration, etc. The narrative of war also persists in Armenia, where representatives of the ruling party silence opposition protests with the need to demarcate the borders with Azerbaijan, even through concessions, in order to avoid a new war. Unlike the narrative of the war in Georgia and Moldova, which deals with Russian aggression in Ukraine, the same theme in the case of Armenia deals with the perception of threat by Azerbaijan.
External interference is treated differently in the government narratives of the three countries. There is talk in Moldova and Armenia that Russia is interested in using pro-Russian opposition politicians to destabilise the two countries from within. Both countries denounce disinformation as one of the main forms of Russian interference. In this regard, Moldova appeals to the support of its Western partners to confront, in an election year, the hybrid threats attributed to Russia. At the same time, in Georgia, the shadow government coordinator, oligarch Bidzina Ivanishvili, and supporters of the ruling party suggested that the West was financing the actors involved in the April-June 2024 protests against the law on “foreign influence agencies”. A similar discrepancy is also observed when it comes to European integration, which has a strictly positive connotation in the discourse of the governments in Chisinau and Yerevan. European integration is presented by them as a kind of lifeline against geopolitical risks of Russian origin. The situation is different in Georgia. European integration narratives are often accompanied by criticism from the Georgian government towards the EU, which is accused of using double standards in opening accession negotiations, favouring Moldova (Agenda.ge, July 2024). In this way, the Tbilisi government is trying to validate the idea that Brussels would treat Georgia “unfairly” (Civil.ge, May 2024).
In lieu of conclusion
The geopolitical narratives used by the governments of Georgia, Moldova and Armenia denote an increasing degree of influence of exogenous processes on the dynamics of domestic politics. As a result, responsibility for failures in the act of governing is diminished or even nullified. Thus, democratic processes are altered to the detriment of transparency, meritocracy and the rule of law under the pressure of narratives about a hypothetical war and the real "hand of Russia" (Moldova and Armenia) or the rather imaginary "hand of the West" (Georgia).
The predominance of war and external interference in the central political discourse of these countries creates a tense internal climate, fuelling suspicion and, respectively, possible (re)pression against critics of the government by the opposition. Although European integration has a positive charge that can serve to overcome emotions of strategic uncertainty in society, in some cases narratives related to the EU can become a new channel for manipulating public opinion in order to maintain power.
Until the war in Ukraine ends, the borders between Armenia and Azerbaijan are bilaterally recognized, and European integration is removed from the dichotomous geopolitical dilemma, current and future governments in these countries will be tempted to exploit these narratives to justify domestic and foreign policy priorities, even if they may contravene the real public interest.
Dionis Cenuşa, Senior Contributor
Dionis Cenușa is a political scientist, researcher at the Institute of Political Sciences at Liebig-Justus University in Giessen, Germany, MA degree in Interdisciplinary European Studies from the College of Europe in Warsaw.
Areas of research: European Neighborhood Policy, EU-Moldova relationship, EU's foreign policy and Russia, migration and energy security.
Follow Dionis Cenușa on
Twitter
IPN publishes in the Op-Ed rubric opinion pieces submitted by authors not affiliated with our editorial board. The opinions expressed in these articles do not necessarily coincide with the opinions of our editorial board.
IE
See related articles:
- Cristina Gerasimov says how €1.8bn package announced by Ursula von der Leyen will be used
- Vladimir Bolea and Ursula von der Leyen discuss EU support for Moldovan farmers
- Gagauz governor sanctioned by EU among other officials of the autonomy
- EP resolution on strengthening Moldova’s resilience against Russian interference ahead of elections
- Vacation in Vienna and European money helped Olesea Plugaru start meat business
- What changed in Sweden after joining the EU? Ambassador Katarina Fried
- EU integration is a fundamental option, Romanian official
- Foreign Minister greets new ambassador of France in Chisinau
- Transition to green economy and energy efficiency are becoming priorities for Moldova
- Best way to deal with misinformation is to tell the truth, ambassador
- Opening of Denmark’s embassy in Chisinau was based on Moldova’s desire to get closer to EU
- Moldova is facing an election. IPN interview with Denmark’s first ambassador to Moldova
- 76% of respondents of Entrepreneurs’ Barometer support European integration
- EU and ILO donate new body cameras for labor inspectors
- Chișinău-Tiraspol tourist train restored after a break of 20 years
- EU is considering providing emergency aid to Moldovan farmers
- Government banks on diaspora’s active involvement in EU accession process
- Russian troops must be withdrawn from Moldova immediately. PM Recean’s message at UN Assembly
- European financing for transport projects
- Priest Andrei Rusu: Religion remains a pillar of European values
- Young people of Moldova more actively involved civically thanks to German partners
- All parliamentary majorities in Moldova were pro-European, Igor Boțan
- Global processes can only be influenced together, Prof. Dr. Norbert Lammert
- Moldova's integration into EU is a strategic objective, former President of German Bundestag
- Being part of EU means acting unitedly in confronting common challenges. IPN interview with Prof. Dr. Norbert Lammert
-
- Interior Ministry veterans explain why it is important to vote in Oct. 20 referendum
- What Europe’s future enlargement chief Marta Kos means for Moldova
- It’s time to mobilize and complete European path, ex-deputy prime minister
- Triangle commitments. What advantages do we enjoy
- Firm support for Moldova’s European future
- We are stronger, statements at Moldova Partnership Platform
- Victoria Cociug: European Commission’s money goes to salaries of researchers through Horizon Europe
- Vitalie Moraru: €5.38 million was attracted by Moldova through Horizon Europe
- Aurelia Hanganu: Horizon Europe involves identification of solutions for all aspects of life
- European integration of Moldova’s research sector. IPN debate
- Stable and democratic Moldova will ensure stability in entire region, Romanian official
- “We will help Moldova to become a European state,” French foreign minister
-
- German Foreign Minister in Chisinau: We support Moldova’s and Ukraine's freedom
-
- €9 million in financial support from Denmark
- Financial commitments at Moldova Partnership Platform: €80m in grants and €300m in loans
- Mihai Popșoi: Support mobilized through Moldova Partnership Platform is crucial
- Luminița Odobescu: Moldova is not alone and today’s meeting confirms this
- Fifth edition of Moldova Partnership Platform underway
- Gabrielius Landsbergis: Lithuania will continue to stand by Moldova on its European path
- Fuss at Palace of the Republic. Foreign delegations expected to arrive early Tuesday
- Daniel Vodă: Our friends who want a European Moldova come to Partnership Platform
- Moldova has no other more beneficial path than joining EU, Nicolae Timofti
- PM of Luxemburg: We want to stand by Moldova on path to great European family
- Citizens for Europe about EU accession, sovereignty and neutrality of country
- Mihai Popșoi: After trying to spoil our relationship with Ukraine, some act similarly with regard to Hungary
- 65 delegations expected to attend Conference of Moldova Partnership Platform in Chisinau
- PM Recean in Bratislava: Slovakia’s support is very important for us
- (Pre-) EU Accession in 2030: The Western Balkans and the Eastern Wing - Ukraine, Moldova, and Georgia, Analysis by Dionis Cenușa
- Three more parties request to be registered as participants in referendum
- Model and text of ballot paper for referendum approved
- PAS will apply to be registered as a participant in referendum with option “For”
- Justice sector reforms and fight against corruption are founding elements for any democracy, forum
- Latvia reaffirms its support for Moldova’s European path
- Opportunity to create Economic and Social Committee in Moldova discussed at roundtable
- Ex-President of Estonia: It is our duty for Moldova to become part of EU; we experienced similar challenges
- Sections of Chisinau streets to be closed to traffic due to Euro Marathon
- Tatiana Romaniuc: Eu4Culture contributed to developing culture in Cahul
- Parascovia Marandici: Costești Socio-Cultural Center provides activities to suit everyone’s taste
- Diana Josu-Braniște: With EU support, cultural institutions in Ialoveni are being modernized
- Péter Szijjártó: Hungary offers support for Moldova to join EU as soon as possible
- EU investments in Moldova’s cultural sector. IPN debate
- European integration and geopolitical games of Russian Church in Moldova
- Hungarian minister of foreign affairs to visit Chisinau
- Mayors urge people to vote “Yes” at October 20 referendum
- Simplified procedure for introducing cosmetic products from EU into Moldova
- Donald Tusk in Parliament: Poland will continue to support Moldova’s European path
- Donald Tusk: Enlargement and cooperation among EU countries is in the interest of all of Europe
- Polish PM Donald Tusk welcomed in Chisinau
- Maria Băcioi: In any business, maintaining quality is the hardest thing to do
- Dorina Baciu: Our cheeses are exclusive and of a high quality
- CCI deputy chairman: We support entrepreneurs through various financing programs
- Mihai Ghimpu calls on former Presidents to support and promote October 20 referendum
- New landfill and sorting and composting station to be built in Cahul
- EU4Business Initiative, contributions to development of SMEs in Moldova. IPN debate
- Deputy Premier at Bled Strategic Forum: EU enlargement is a historic opportunity
- Ion Ceban: National Alternative Movement will support referendum on amending Constitution
- EU provides Moldova with €9.5 million to address security challenges
- Almost 50% of Moldovans are for amending Constitution to enshrine path to EU, poll
- Three European Premiers to visit Moldova in September
- Chief of European Public Prosecutor’s Office assures that Moldova will be further assisted to reform justice system
- European Chief Prosecutor: Whole society must be involved in fight against corruption, not just justice system
- Deputy Premier Popșoi to attend 19th Bled Strategic Forum
- Libraries will promote European values through reading within national campaign
- Mihai Popșoi at GLOBSEC: European course ensures prosperity and growth for Moldova
- European Chief Prosecutor Kovesi to visit Chisinau Sep.2
- Not having running water is a major disadvantage, says rural mayor
- Lozova mayor praises Clean Water for All, part of EU4Moldova Program
-
- Clean Water for All project to benefit over 19,000 people in Straseni
- Moldova to negotiate €200M loan for reforestation
-
- EU4Moldova Program: Local Communities. IPN livecast
- Baltic leaders sign declaration supporting Moldova’s EU membership bid
- EU Ambassador: This year Moldova’s independence takes on a new meaning
- Independence Day wreath-laying: ‘Let us all come together as a nation’
- Maia Sandu: We choose a future in peace and well-being
- Born Independent: Moldova is a young country that needs to put in a lot of work to prosper
- Moldova to host Electro Marathon on September 7 and 8
-
- Moldova Partnership Platform to assemble Sep.17
- Olaf Scholz in Chisinau: Germany stands firmly with Moldova
- EU4Moldova, Cahul and Ungheni. IPN debate
-
- Ion Dolganiuc: Colibași market modernized thanks to EU4Moldova: Key Regions Program
- Nicolae Dandiș: EU4Moldova: Key Regions is one of the most effective programs we have benefited from
- Moldova, Italy to cooperate in fighting crime
- What it really means to be European: lessons learned from the EU experience. Op-Ed by Laurențiu Plesca
- German Chancellor arriving in Chisinau today
- Moldova, Sweden sign defense cooperation agreement
- Mihai Tîrșu: Moldova is quite advanced in implementing EU Directive on energy performance of buildings
- Ion Muntean: EU has a very active role in improving energy efficiency in Moldova’s residential sector
- Chisinau resident: After energy efficiency improvements, we pay only for what we actually consume
- Young Frenchman cycles across Europe from Chisinau to Brussels
- Improving energy efficiency in the residential sector with European support. IPN Debate
- ‘I know you care about the country’, president Sandu tells Moldovans in GOTV effort
- Moldova and the EU: an advantageous Partnership in Progress. Op-Ed written by Dr. Dorina Baltag
- Unions, employers propose 6,000 lei minimum salary from 2025
-
- Moldova and Spain complete procedures for mutual recognition of driving licenses
- An opportunity to profoundly transform the everyday life of Moldovans. Op-Ed by Laurențiu Plesca
- Over 2,500 children participated in European Excursion educational program
- Informal employment in Moldova is second-highest in Europe
- European support for Moldovan industry: benefits for employers and employees. IPN debate
- Dual education has gained momentum, says state secretary
- Ionel Factory HR manager praises dual education as vacancy-filling solution
- State partially compensates expenses of companies implementing dual education
- 2024 Euro Marathon to take place Sep. 8
- EU and Moldova’s military resilience. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- Estonia to buy armored vehicles for Moldova valued at €46M
- ALDE stays out of presidential race, but will promote EU referendum
- German Chancellor Scholz to visit Moldova Aug. 21
-
- Ludotheque inaugurated at Popeasca secondary school with Italy's support
- Grants for investigative journalists
- “Through Art in Europe”, short film contest for students
- Three cars bought with EU support reach social workers in northern Moldova
- Border between Ukraine and Moldova safer thanks to EU project
-
- EU urges Moldovan citizens to beware of Russian fakes
- 219 households became energy efficient thanks to EU support
- Over 39,000 vouchers redeemed as part of “Rabla for household appliances” program
-
- EU-funded program increases Moldova’s energy resilience
- European integration means not only geopolitics, but also internal reform, Expert-Grup
- Lithuania provides National Army with thermal night vision devices and drones
- Young people from southern Moldova bring Europe at home
- European Romania versus “Moldovenist” Republic of Moldova and integration into EU. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- Siegfried Mureșan: Staying at home on referendum day means playing into Russia’s hands
- 54% of respondents consider EU is Moldova’s main development partner
- Over 66% of Moldovans intend to participate in referendum
- 20 firefighters left for Greece for staff rotation in pre-positioning mission
- EU accession referendums in member states and Republic of Moldova. Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Green House Program to extend nationwide
- Ludmila Pavlov: Thanks to EU support, education in Moldova moves to a new level
- Iargara supplied with new waste management equipment with EU support
- Gennady Rybakov: Francophone bilingual classes are part of educational system adjusted to European standards
- Olga Balmus: If we want qualified specialists, we need to understand value of European investments
- Quality education in Moldova, role of European projects. Context and impact. IPN Debate
- Radiology and medical imaging laboratory at Criuleni Health Center, thanks to support of EU and UNDP
- Moldova to benefit from EU investments in road infrastructure at mouths of the Danube
- Cristina Gerasimov: Moldova will double its efforts towards joining EU
- 150,000 families will benefit from vouchers to replace old appliances
- Romanian MEP Rareș Bogdan elected vice-chair of EP Committee on Foreign Affairs
- Leonid Boaghe: Creating energy communities will increase efficiency of the sector
- Dinu Bubulici: Advantages of diversifying renewable energy sources can also be obtained through European projects
- Dorina Onici: People must take advantage of EU opportunities regarding transition to alternative energy
- Transforming energy sector through European funding: Concrete examples and lessons learned. IPN debate
- Cristina Gerasimov: We have a rare window of opportunity that history offers us
- Breastfeeding Caravan starts in Hâncești
- European integration reflected in constitutions of member states. Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Victor Parlicov: Bills can be reduced only by rationalizing energy consumption
- World leaders pledge to continue cooperation to maintain peace in Moldova
- For 19 of 51 LAGs, no sources of funding have been yet identified
- Specialists in European integration gathered in Chisinau to share experience
- Moldova’s accession to EU: expected advantages. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- Moldova at European Political Community Summit
- Next year's elections are real stake of those who intend to take part in electoral competition, opinions
- Ursula von der Leyen, at the helm of European Commission by Moldovans’ will as well
- European Commission grant for road infrastructure rehabilitation
- European Parliament seeks adequate support for Moldova and Ukraine, Siegfried Mureșan
- 219 households improve energy efficiency with financial support of EU
- MP Radu Marian about how foreign funding was used
- Viorel Furdui: Over 80% of local administrations are pro-European
- Andrei Curăraru: Affiliation to European community must be constantly communicated through concrete examples
- Natalia Stercul: Citizens’ involvement in European integration process must be major goal of society
- Advantages and responsibilities of citizen in strengthening country’s European future. IPN debate
- Ministry of Energy launches first tender contests for large renewable energy capacities
- 20 Moldovan servicemen to take part in EU operation in Bosnia and Herzegovina
- EU donates patrol vehicles and body cameras to police in Moldova
- Poland and UNDP to renovate and equip one of 35 model schools in Moldova
- EU contributes to supporting energy efficiency projects in Moldova’s residential sector
- Ambassador Felix Baumann: Moldova continues to promote democracy and freedom
- Switzerland assisted Moldova through projects to the value of 6bn lei
- Georgia’s EU accession suspended
- Iurie Ciocan: All political camps are already campaigning on referendum
- Citizens for Europe: Everyone must get involved for country’s European future
- UK general election: lessons for Eurosceptics. Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Anatolie Nosatyi: Second radar is being assembled and will be delivered to Moldova in 2025