“The irony is that the collapse of the Soviet Union was accompanied by other outrageous crimes instead: almost all public property became private property controlled by the former communist nomenclature or by thugs who became oligarchs overnight. It would be strange if, after remembering and understanding these things, there would still be restorative nostalgic currents in Moldova...”
***
Plans to exploit nostalgia for the Soviet Union
On 30 December 2022 there will be 100 years since the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics was founded. Russian entrepreneurs have already stamped a medal to mark the USSR centenary and are waiting for orders from nostalgics who, in turn, are waiting for unifying ideas for those about 270 million people scattered around the world who were born in the Soviet Union. The PR specialists who helped to shape public opinion around the 70th and 75th anniversaries of the Victory in the Great Patriotic War, transformed into propaganda projects like “Mozhem povtorit” (“We can repeat”), or the 100th anniversary of the October Revolution, are now happily helping with the promotion of the USSR-100 project as well.
The main goal is to exploit nostalgia for nothing short of a lost paradise. It is difficult to say whether or not the propagandists will succeed in their goal. Today, everything depends on the outcome of the “special military operation” in Ukraine, which will be conquered in “two or three days… a couple of weeks, tops”. The destruction of Ukraine and its people is part of a project to launch the USSR 2.0 version, according to the Belarusian dictator Alexander Lukashenko, or to restore the Russian empire, according to a former advisor to President Putin.
Either way, exploiting nostalgia for the defunct USSR has been planned for the entire USSR centenary year. The standoff reached in the Ukraine adventure has put on hold the grand plans to restore the empire. At any rate, the anniversary is a good occasion to reflect on the USSR project and its impact on the Moldovan society and others, which broke away from the Soviet empire in 1991. Therefore, the phenomenon of nostalgia for the Soviet Union deserves continued attention and understanding. First of all, we must understand that nostalgia is something absolutely natural and practically inevitable. Second, it is important to understand that exploiting nostalgic feelings has its limits, and they must be constantly narrowed. Third, it is necessary to undertake sustained efforts to show that the lost Soviet paradise was actually built on an infernal machinery that ground down tens of millions of lives just to fabricate a formidable mystification, which many, sadly, continue to believe in today.
Gauging nostalgic attitudes in Moldova
Before proceeding to estimate the extent of nostalgia for the Soviet Union in the Republic of Moldova, it is important to clarify what specialists in social and political sciences understand when they study nostalgia. Practicing sociologists found that only a few years after the collapse of the USSR, an active process of mythologizing history was set in motion. Such a process inevitably follows the classic trajectory of sliding into something known as the golden age or the lost paradise myth.
In this process, nostalgia manifests as an “intellectual and emotional construct that distorts the image of a certain period of history”. This happens naturally, because with the passage of time there is a need to reconstruct the past as a kaleidoscope of images. This is how longing appears for images that either existed in reality or only summarily “reconstruct” a utopia projected not into the future, but rather into a happy and irretrievable past.
So, being based on individual or collective, direct or implicit experience, nostalgia can have various manifestations. For our practical purposes, it is important to distinguish that, broadly, nostalgia can be of two kinds: restorative and reflective. The first one involves emotional idealization of past experience that underpins the need to repeat this experience. In the latter case, it is an attempt to understand it: what was good, what was bad in the idealized period, and why the bad things prevailed and eventually buried the longed-for ideal.
In Moldova, the Public Opinion Barometer poll measured, on several occasions (in 2009, 2016, and 2018), the extent of nostalgia for the Soviet Union. It appears that the Moldovans’ nostalgia is more reflective (see Chart 1) then restorative.
Chart 1.
Interestingly enough, the number of nostalgics has increased with time. But this is no wonder, considering the massive 2014 bank fraud that involved many purported pro-Europeans. Later on, the attitudes have relaxed towards the initial state. Anyway, it is worth noting that the share of those who want the Soviet empire rebuilt (see Chart 2) is significantly lower than the percentage of those who regret its dissolution.
Chart 2.
Conclusions
Nostalgia for the defunct Soviet Union is still strong in Moldova, but significantly less so than in other former Soviet republics. The explanation for why nostalgia in Moldova is more reflective then restorative is in that our political elites simply exploited this nostalgia before disavowing any USSR restoration ideas almost completely.
Notably, in the 2001 legislative election the Moldovan Communist Party (PCRM) won a whopping 70% supermajority on the promise to take Moldova into a hypothetical Union of Sovereign Republics alongside Russia and Belarus, only to flip-flop just a year and a half later, when it nominally changed course to European integration. Today, nostalgic feelings towards the USSR are intensely played on by the Shor Party, for example, with its pretended intentions of reinstating state control over private business, reanimating state companies, restoring collective farms on a mass scale, offering all kinds of free services to people, and so on.
To keep any restorative ideas at bay, it is important to remind nostalgic people - in a civil manner and using ample evidence - that the USSR was a totalitarian state, founded on lies and crimes, which completely replaced the promises enshrined in the November 1917 proclamations, and which practiced terror against its own citizens, including collectivization, deportation, destruction of churches and annihilation of the clergy, among many other heinous crimes. All this evildoing was done only for the Soviet Union to one day collapse under the burden of its own economic inconsistencies.
The irony, however, is that the collapse of the Soviet Union was accompanied by other outrageous crimes instead: almost all public property became private property controlled by the former communist nomenclature or by thugs who became oligarchs overnight. It would be strange if, after remembering and understanding these things, there would still be restorative nostalgic currents in Moldova.
Antinostalgia
See related articles:
- War as state ideologeme of Putin’s Russia. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- In new times with new symbols, Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Centenary of collapsed empire. Brief guide for the nostalgic. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- Z0ZZ – Year of centenary and of efforts to restore USSR... Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Octavian Țîcu: Moldova’s perspective is no other than European and alongside Romania
- Igor Sharov: Nostalgia for USSR can be cured by information and acknowledgement of history
- Why and how did USSR disappear? Why does it cause nostalgia yet? IPN debate
- Igor Boțan: Triumphal march of the pro-Soviet nostalgic was interrupted after April 7, 2009 youth protests
- Marin Gherman: Nostalgia for USSR in Ukraine is at lower level than in Moldova
- Igor Boțan: Government will be helped if it fulfills commitments
- Why did USSR appear and how did it work? Why does it cause nostalgia yet? IPN debate
- Virgiliu Pâslariuc: USSR collapsed, but post-Soviet space remained media and energy colony of Russia
- Russian world as substitute for USSR. Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Day of betrayal and nostalgia... Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Igor Boțan: Kremlin’s mistakes in relation to Ukraine are total
- Valentin Dolganiuc: Moldovans are not nostalgic for USSR; they are victims of propaganda
- Arcadie Barbăroșie: I think Moldova will ultimately unite with Romania
- Evolution of Russia’s aggression against Ukraine and its influence on nostalgia for USSR. IPN debate
- Nostalgia ahead of apogee. Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Holodomor and Ukrainian identity construct. Lesson for Moldova. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- Historian Virgiliu Bîrlădeanu: Anti-Soviet resistance was platform that ensured changes
- Virgiliu Bîrlădeanu: Governments kept indifferent attitude to anti-communist resistance movement
- Anti-communist resistance movements created platforms for national renaissance
- Strange manifestations of nostalgia... Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Nostalgia for chimeras or whyt unionist project stagnates. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- Nostalgia for grandeur of empire. Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Nostalgia for government of enemies of the people. Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Neutrality as a status of vassalage of Moldova to Moscow. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- Nostalgia for red revolution... Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Main enemy of nostalgia for USSR. Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Anneli Ute Gabanyi: Before Fall of Berlin Wall, they didn’t speak about Red Army’s crimes in GDR
- Historian Virgiliu Bîrlădeanu: Bessarabians remember how they were thrown into minefields
- Igor Boțan: Russia takes revenge following destruction of myths it created
- Final stage of World War II: reality and myths about USSR’s and Anti-Hitler Alliance’s contribution. IPN debate
- Igor Boțan: In this war, they use all kinds of weapons, including energy ones
- Nicolae Negru: Russian propaganda in Moldova exists due to political forces fueled by Russia
- Anatol Petrencu: Russia will be defeated and will pay reparations
- USSR’s participation in World War II: about real victories and defeats, about what propaganda does not say, about what myths and nostalgia reveal. IPN debate
- Failure of attempts to resuscitate nostalgic feelings. Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Anatol Țăranu: Better life will eliminate any nostalgia for the past
- Marin Gherman: In Ukraine, the narrative of victory prevails
- Igor Boțan: Russia is going through a period of revanchism
- Who started World War II and why? Propaganda myths as source of nostalgia for USSR. IPN debate
- Soviet nostalgia resuscitates Romanophobia in Moldova. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- Valentin Constantinov: Dictators care only about personal power. IPN interview
- Distorted historical narrative as ideological weapon of Russian imperialism. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- Valentin Constantinov: Cult of Stalin’s personality was exposed in ten years
- Doctor of history: In Soviet period, propaganda hushed up repressive actions
- Valentin Constantinov: The further we are form Russia, the better we live
- Nostalgia for dictatorship and violence. Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Unpolished reality about petty baton passed by red army to Putin’s army. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- Igor Boțan: Russia has always had imperialistic ambitions
- Col. (Ret) Andrei Covrig: Vladimir Putin aims to destroy Ukraine
- Valentin Constantinov: No dismemberment of empires occurred without wars
- Nostalgia for military grandeur of USSR as explanation for approval of current invasions. IPN debate
- Nostalgias for Soviet militia born out of NKVD, Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Protest of nostalgic serf. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- Nostalgia for voting without elections... Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Fatal price of Russian imperial nostalgia. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- Boris Negru: Dismemberment of USSR should be regarded as a rule as empires appear and disappear
- Anatol Petrencu: Russia today is not at all attractive
- Igor Boțan: Atrocities in Bucha are effects of propagandistic exploitation of Soviet nostalgia
- Basic human rights and freedoms in USSR: Myths and realities. IPN debate
- Amnesia and moral degradation of nostalgic Communists. Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Russian and German models for learning lessons of history. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- Nostalgia at propaganda’s service. Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Nostalgia after empire and Gagauz factor in Moldovan politics. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- Igor Boțan: Gorbachev didn’t focus on economic recovery and USSR disappeared
- Grigore Belostecinic: Gorbachev really wanted to save Soviet Union
- Anatol Țaranu: Soviet system was built based on element of terror
- Why are the nostalgic wrong when they attribute role of demolisher of USSR to Mikhail Gorbachev? IPN debate
- Mykhailo Podolyak: Cooperation of post-Soviet countries with Russia will harm them
- The Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact in the mirror of the Kremlin’s imperialistic nostalgia. Op-Ed by Anatol Țaranu
- Ukrainian TV channel: Russia will attempt to annex territories of five countries in autumn
- Facts beat nostalgia. Op-Ed by Victor Pelin
- Infarction and death of USSR. Birth of Soviet nostalgia. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- Anatol Petrecu: Nostalgic people should also accept hidden part about life in USSR. IPN interview
- Anatol Petrencu: We cannot accept aggressive policy of Russia
- Anatol Petrencu: Soviet Union was a state based on fear and blackmail
- Historian Anatol Petrencu: Those who are nostalgic for USSR idealize a criminal past
- Igor Boțan: There is clear evidence that famine of 1946-1947 in MSSR was organized
- Vasile Bumacov: Only agents of influence “believe” famine wasn’t organized
- Lidia Pădureac: Famine of 1946-1947 is a crime against humanity and does not have statute of limitations
- Was famine of MSSR of 1946-1947 organized or not? Could and wanted Soviet authorities to prevent devastating effects of this? IPN debate
- Iasi-Chisinau operation between Soviet nostalgia and Europeanization policy. Op-Ed by Anatol Țăranu
- 100 years of USSR and 31 years without USSR: Nostalgia for Chimeras. IPN debate
- Victor Juc: Bad state of affairs fuels nostalgia for earlier times
- Igor Boțan: We need a policy of communication on problems related to European course
- Rodica Ciobanu: We need to cultivate civic sprit of citizens